AITA for telling a hospice patient the truth about his prognosis after his daughter begged me not to?
I have been a hospice volunteer for six years now, though I spent thirty years before that as an ICU nurse, so I know how to sit with hard truths. Last month I was assigned to Earl (81M), a retired mechanic with pancreatic cancer who had maybe three weeks left. His daughter Denise (52F) pulled me aside on my very first visit and asked me, please, never to tell her father how bad things really were. She said he was a fighter and that knowing would take that away from him. For two weeks I just held his hand and listened to him talk about his old fishing boat. But last Tuesday he grabbed my wrist and asked me straight out, am I dying soon, Peggy, and don't you lie to me like everybody else. I could not do it. I have watched too many people leave this world angry because nobody let them finish their goodbyes. There is a time to keep silence and a time to speak, and I felt that time had come. So I told him gently that yes, his body was shutting down, and that there was still time to say what needed saying. He cried, but he thanked me, and he called his estranged son that same night. Denise found out and was furious, said I went behind her back and broke a promise that was never mine to make. She complained to my hospice supervisor. Now she will not look at me when she visits, and the other volunteers are split down the middle on whether I should have kept my mouth shut.
What People Are Saying
you dont get to steal a man's own death from him just to spare someone else's feelings. he asked, you answered, that's respect not betrayal.
A dying man asked a direct question and deserved a direct answer. The daughter's request was never yours to honor above his autonomy. Not the A-hole.
you dont lie to a dying man just to spare someone elses feelings. he asked you straight, you owed him straight back.
A man deserves to know his own harvest is coming in. You did right by him. Not the A-hole.
omg this made me tear up 😭 he asked her directly not to lie tho?? NTA, that goodbye call to his son mattered more than staying quiet ever could
NTA 💪 he GRABBED her wrist and asked her not to lie. Respecting HIS voice over his daughter's comfort is the right call. That phone call to his son says it all.
NTA. He asked her directly and used her name. Dying people deserve truth, not a script written by someone else's fear. Good on her for calling his son that night.
Dear, thirty years of nursing taught you when silence helps and when it harms. He asked you point blank. NTA, and Denise will thank you eventually.
A promise made on someone else's behalf to withhold truth from a dying man was never binding to begin with; NTA (though Denise's grief is understandable too).
He asked you directly and you told him the truth with love in your heart! NTA, that man deserved his goodbyes. Blessings to you for your courage. 🌸
Should I stay in my house, move downtown, or move near my daughter in Ohio?
Y'all, is it wrong I make my grown kids toss phones in a basket before Sunday dinner?!
Should Bill and I go to our son's in Denver, our daughter's in Austin, or just stay put for Christma
AITA for making my son pay off the dent he put in my truck out of pocket instead of filing insurance
@selene_tarotmoon
the moon doesn't lie to us in our final hours... he asked for truth and you gave it, that's a sacred thing not a sin 🌙