pinionsGet The App
Verdict In

AIO for leaving a date when he ordered for me after I'd already ordered?

me (29F). third date with a guy (34M), going well honestly. nice place, his pick. waiter comes, i order the branzino. he says, to the waiter, not to me, "she'll have the chicken, she said she wanted to try it." i had said, an hour earlier in the car, that the chicken sounded good. i then read the menu and ordered a different thing. i said no, the branzino. he laughed and said to the waiter "she'll have the chicken" again like it was a bit. the waiter looked at me. i said branzino, and then i said actually i'm going to head out, and i left. he's texted twice. the second one said i embarrassed him over a joke and that he was being playful because i'd been indecisive in the car. my friends are split down the middle, which is why i'm here. half say that's a two second thing to have walked out over. half say he did it twice after i corrected him.

#aio#relationships

asked by @crystald_glam · Aug 18, 2026 · 307 votes · 6 comments

Pick a side in the app

OverreactingNot Overreacting

Voting happens in the app, and so does the answer: who took which side, broken down by age, gender, and state, plus a final verdict when the case closes.

Vote & See The Split · Free

@BRI_ROLLERQUEEN+204

NOT OVERREACTING. ONCE is a joke. TWICE after you said no out loud in front of a witness is him showing you who decides.

@ashleyn_fit+198

Not overreacting. And "you'd been indecisive" is him explaining why you needed managing, which is worse than the original thing.

@bianca_bridalbliss+189

The waiter looking at you is the detail. A stranger clocked it in real time. You're not inventing the dynamic.

@priyac_eats+176

NOR. My boyfriend picks every restaurant and would sooner die than order for me. Choosing where to eat and choosing what I eat are not the same permission.

@derekc_builds+163

as a guy who is bad at dating — this is not a close call and i'm surprised your friends are split

@crystald_glam+154

the split is basically age tbh. the older ones said walk, the younger ones said he was just being goofy

Join the argument in the app.

MORE LIKE THIS

Should I accept a dinner invitation from a woman in my book club or stay home?

264 votes

is it weird to still use the mug my ex gave me for coffee every morning...

113 votes

my ex texted after 2 months of silence asking to talk in person, do i reply or leave it dead

185 votes

AIO for being annoyed she only said lol when i said i missed leg day

60 votes