pinionsGet The App
Verdict In

AITA for keeping all the profit from a jacket i found on a thrift trip with my friend?

ok so my friend priya (22f) and i have been doing thrift runs together for like 8 months, we split gas both ways. we never signed anything but we always just verbally split resell profit over $20 if we're both digging through the same bin, thats just been the vibe. last saturday we're at a goodwill outlet and I'm the one who actually dug through a whole cart of junk while she was on her phone, found a vintage carhartt detroit jacket for $6. she was standing right next to me when i found it but she didnt touch it or help look. fixed it up a little, sold it on depop for $180. didnt tell her bc technically she wasnt the one who found it, she was just physically present. she found out bc a mutual friend saw the depop sale and mentioned it in our group chat like "omg nina that sold fast" and priya asked how much and i said $180 and she went silent then texted me privately saying i owe her half since we were together when i found it and thats always been the rule. now shes saying i only follow the split rule when its convenient for me and brought up two other times i technically shortchanged her. i think finding something in a shared bin while shes not even looking should count as mine. she's not responding to my texts and we have a thrift trip planned for next weekend that is now extremely awkward

#aita#friends

asked by @nina_thrifts · Aug 22, 2026 · 265 votes · 6 comments

Voting happens in the app, and so does the answer: who took which side, broken down by age, gender, and state, plus a final verdict when the case closes.

Vote & See The Split · Free

@carlas_foodtruck

in business your word is everything mija. you had a system, you bent it when it paid off. that's not partnership 🌮

@jrsneakshead

bro made 180 off a $6 flip and still tryna dodge the split ngl thats wild YTA fr

@frankd_ny

Ya had a rule. Ya broke the rule. Then ya act surprised she's mad. YTA, simple as that.

@felixz_infosec

no contract, sure, but verbal agreements have an audit trail called witnesses. group chat just leaked your logs. YTA.

@rusty_ridesfree

Brotherhood means the split holds even when it stings. You broke the code. YTA.

@frankd_ny

YTA. Ya had a rule for 8 months and ya broke it the second it paid off big. That's not business, that's greedy.

Join the argument in the app.

MORE LIKE THIS

AITA for banning my best friend's kids from my coop after we lost two hens?

176 votes

AITA for reporting my chess club co-captain for using an engine during practice?

248 votes

AITA for going through my roommate's phone after finding my $22 dress on her Depop?

235 votes

AITA for waiting a week to tell my roommate his gf was flirting with me

189 votes